ADVANCED PLANT ECOLOGY · ECOSYSTEM STRUCTURE AND FUNCTIONS
A lion eats a zebra. A zebra eats grass. That is a food chain — simple, straight, and easy to draw. But the lion also eats wildebeest, the zebra is also eaten by hyenas, and the grass is also eaten by grasshoppers, which are eaten by birds, which are eaten by eagles. Real feeding relationships are not straight lines. They are webs.
This lesson moves from single food chains to food webs, explains keystone species and trophic cascades, and then compares the three ecological pyramids — number, biomass and energy — including the two famous cases where a pyramid turns upside down, and the one case where it never does.
Learning objectives
- Distinguish a food chain from a food web, and explain why webs describe real ecosystems better.
- Read a food web diagram: follow the arrows, find trophic levels, and spot omnivores and species that feed at more than one level.
- Define a keystone species and explain a trophic cascade, using the sea otter–sea urchin–kelp and Yellowstone wolf examples.
- Construct and interpret pyramids of number, biomass and energy, and explain why each can be upright or inverted.
- Use the ten percent law to calculate energy at each trophic level in an energy pyramid, and explain why an energy pyramid can never be inverted.
- Explain why food webs are usually more stable than single chains, and what can still make a web collapse.
1. From food chains to food webs
A food chain is a single sequence showing who eats whom: grass → grasshopper → frog → snake. The arrow points in the direction energy flows — from the food to the feeder. Food chains are useful for teaching, and for the worked examples in the previous post, because they show the direction of energy flow clearly.
But a food chain is a simplification. In a real ecosystem, almost every organism has more than one food source and more than one predator. A frog eats grasshoppers, flies and moths. A grasshopper is eaten by frogs, birds and spiders. A snake eats frogs, mice and small birds. When all of those feeding links are drawn together, the result is a food web: a network of interconnected food chains in one community.
The previous post introduced the two great channels of energy flow — the grazing food chain and the detritus food chain — and the Y-shaped model that joins them. See Ecosystem Structure and Energy Flow: Y-Shaped Models and the Ten Percent Law (Post 1 in this series). A food web takes the next step: it draws all the grazing and detritus links together, so that one organism can appear in several chains at once.
| Feature | Food chain | Food web |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | One straight sequence | A network of many linked sequences |
| What it shows | One path of energy flow | All the feeding paths in a community |
| Number of food sources per organism | One (in the diagram) | Usually several |
| What happens if one link breaks | The chain is broken | Energy can often flow by another route |
| Use | Teaching, simple calculations | Describing real ecosystems, predicting the effects of removing or adding a species |
2. Reading a food web
A food web diagram looks crowded at first. Work through it in a fixed order, and it becomes readable.
- Find the producers at the base. Green plants, algae and cyanobacteria. All energy enters here, as in the Y-shaped model.
- Follow the arrows. In a standard food web, an arrow points from the organism being eaten to the organism eating it — the direction energy flows. Grass → grasshopper means the grasshopper eats the grass. (Some textbooks draw arrows the other way, from eater to eaten; always check the key on the diagram you are given.)
- Count the links for one organism. A herbivore with three arrows leaving it is eaten by three different predators. A predator with four arrows arriving at it eats four different prey species.
- Find the trophic levels — and the exceptions. Producers are level 1, herbivores level 2, small carnivores level 3, and so on, as in Post 1. But in a web, many organisms feed at more than one level. An omnivorous crow is level 2 when it eats seeds and level 3 when it eats insects. A fox that eats berries, rabbits and frogs spans three levels.
- Find the decomposers and detritivores. They are often drawn to one side, with arrows arriving from every level, because they feed on dead material from all levels — exactly as in the detritus arm of the Y model.
2.1 A grassland web, step by step
Take a grassland as an example. The producers are grasses and wildflowers. The primary consumers include grasshoppers, rabbits and deer. The secondary consumers include frogs (eating insects), insect-eating birds and shrews. The tertiary consumers include snakes, foxes and hawks. The top predator is the lion — or, in many grasslands, the eagle or the wolf.
Now add the cross-links that turn the chains into a web. The fox eats rabbits, mice and frogs. The hawk eats mice, snakes and small birds. The snake eats frogs and mice. The shrew eats insects and worms. The grasshopper is eaten by the frog, the bird and the shrew. No single chain contains all of this. Remove the frogs, and the snake still has mice; remove the grasshoppers, and the birds still have other insects. That redundancy is the web's strength — and the subject of Section 4.
2.2 An oak-tree web: one tree, hundreds of links
A single oak tree can support a whole food web. Caterpillars, aphids and beetles eat its leaves. Squirrels and jays eat its acorns. Woodpeckers eat the insects in its bark. Spiders eat the flies that visit its flowers. Owls eat the mice that shelter in its roots. Fungi break down its fallen leaves, and earthworms eat the leaf litter.
The oak web also shows why the word "web" matters for plants. A plant ecologist studying this tree is not studying one chain — oak → caterpillar → bird — but a network in which the same oak feeds herbivores, seed-eaters, bark-feeders and decomposers at the same time, and in which the birds that eat the caterpillars also eat the spiders that eat the flies. Change one link — for example, a year with very few acorns — and the effects spread through the web in several directions at once.
3. Keystone species and trophic cascades
Most species in a web can be removed with only a small effect, because other species take over their links. A few species cannot. A keystone species is a species whose effect on its community is far larger than its abundance or biomass would suggest. The name comes from the keystone of an arch: remove it, and the arch falls, even though the keystone is only one small stone.
A keystone species is usually a top predator, but it does not have to be. What matters is that it holds the web together — often by controlling a species that would otherwise dominate, or by creating a habitat other species depend on. Two classic examples show how this works, and why the effect is called a trophic cascade: a change at one trophic level that ripples down (or up) through the levels below (or above) it.
3.1 Sea otters, sea urchins and kelp
Along the Pacific coast of North America, sea otters eat sea urchins. Sea urchins eat kelp — large brown seaweeds that form underwater forests. Kelp forests shelter fish, crabs, snails and many other species.
When sea otters are present, they keep urchin numbers low, kelp forests grow tall, and the whole community is rich in species. When otters were hunted almost to extinction in the 18th and 19th centuries, urchin numbers exploded, the urchins grazed the kelp down to bare rock — an "urchin barren" — and the fish and other species that depended on the kelp disappeared. When otters returned, the kelp forests returned with them.
The otter is a keystone species because its numbers are small — a few otters per kilometre of coast — while its effect is enormous. The cascade runs downwards: fewer otters → more urchins → less kelp → fewer kelp-dependent species. This is a top-down effect: a predator controls the community from the top. It is the opposite of a bottom-up effect, in which the supply of nutrients or producers controls the community from the base — for example, a year with little rain produces little grass, so herbivore numbers fall, so predator numbers fall. Real ecosystems are shaped by both, at different times.
3.2 Wolves in Yellowstone: a cascade with a caution
Grey wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the USA in 1995, after being absent for about 70 years. Elk numbers had been high, and elk browsing had kept young willows and aspens short along streams. After the wolves returned, elk numbers fell and elk spent less time browsing in open riverside areas. Willows and aspens grew taller, beavers returned to build dams in the new willow stands, and the beaver ponds created habitat for fish, amphibians and birds.
The caution matters, and examiners reward students who state it. Later research showed that the recovery of willows and aspens was not caused by wolves alone. Climate, rainfall, the number of beavers, and changes in elk numbers from hunting outside the park all played a part, and in some areas willows did not recover as strongly as the early reports suggested. The Yellowstone story is still a genuine trophic cascade — wolves → elk → willows → beavers — but it is a contributing cause in a web of causes, not a single simple chain. That is exactly what a food-web view predicts: in a web, effects spread in several directions, and several causes act at once.
3.3 How to recognise a keystone species
A species is a keystone species if removing it changes the community far more than removing an ordinary species of similar abundance would. Three tests help:
- Removal experiment: when the species is removed (or disappears), the community changes dramatically — species are lost, or one species takes over. The otter example comes from just such a natural "removal".
- Disproportionate effect: the species is not the most abundant or the largest by biomass. If the most abundant producer is removed, the effect is large but not surprising — it is the base of the web.
- Strong interactions: the species has strong feeding links to species that would otherwise dominate — a predator that eats a competitive dominant herbivore, or a plant that creates habitat for many others.
Other examples students should know: starfish (Pisaster) on rocky shores, which eat mussels that would otherwise crowd out other species — the original keystone experiment, by Robert Paine in the 1960s; and elephants in African savannas, which knock down trees and keep grassland open for grazers.
4. Why webs are usually more stable than chains
A food chain is fragile: break one link, and the chain fails. A food web is usually more stable, for three reasons.
- Alternative food sources. If one prey species becomes scarce, a predator that eats several species can switch to another. The fox that eats rabbits, mice and frogs does not starve when rabbits are scarce.
- Alternative predators. If one predator declines, its prey is still eaten by other predators, so no single prey population explodes unchecked.
- Weak links absorb shocks. Most links in a real web are weak — a predator that only occasionally eats a particular prey. Strong links are few. Mathematical work by Robert May in the 1970s showed that a web of many strong links can actually be unstable, while a web with many weak links tends to return to its previous state after a disturbance. Diversity alone does not guarantee stability; the pattern of strong and weak links matters.
But "usually more stable" is not "always stable". A web can collapse if a keystone species is removed, if a whole trophic level is lost, or if many species are lost at once — for example, through habitat destruction or pollution. And a web with a very long chain is still vulnerable at the top: top predators need a large area and a large prey base, because — as Post 1 showed — only about 10% of the energy at one level reaches the next.
Connectance is one way to measure how linked a web is: it is the proportion of all possible feeding links that actually exist. If a web has S species, the number of possible links is roughly S × S (each species could, in principle, eat each other species, including itself in the count for the formula). Connectance = actual links ÷ possible links. Real food webs usually have low connectance — most species do not eat most other species — and connectance tends to fall as the number of species rises. You do not need to memorise a formula for most exams, but you should be able to explain what connectance means: a web with high connectance has many alternative routes for energy; a web with low connectance has few.
5. Ecological pyramids: three ways to draw a food web as a stack
An ecological pyramid (also called an Eltonian pyramid, after Charles Elton, who introduced it in 1927) is a diagram that stacks the trophic levels of a community as horizontal bars. The producers form the bottom bar, the primary consumers the next bar, and so on up to the top predators. The width of each bar shows how much of something the level contains.
What that "something" is decides which of the three pyramids you are drawing:
| Pyramid | What the bar width shows | Units | Can it be inverted? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pyramid of numbers | Number of individual organisms at each level | Individuals per area (e.g. per m², per hectare) | Yes — e.g. one tree supporting many insects |
| Pyramid of biomass | Total dry mass of organisms at each level at one moment | Mass per area (e.g. g m⁻², kg ha⁻¹) | Yes — e.g. a pond, where tiny phytoplankton support more zooplankton by mass |
| Pyramid of energy | Rate of energy flow through each level | Energy per area per time (e.g. kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹) | No — never |
All three pyramids are drawn for a stated area and, for biomass and energy, a stated time. Without the area and time, the numbers mean nothing — a pyramid for a whole forest cannot be compared with a pyramid for one square metre of pond.
The next three sections take each pyramid in turn, with a worked example for each. The numbers in the worked examples are illustrative teaching examples, not measurements from a real ecosystem, and they use exactly 10% energy transfer at each step so the pattern is easy to follow — as in Post 1.
6. Pyramid of numbers: count the individuals
A pyramid of numbers counts how many individual organisms are present at each trophic level in a stated area at a stated time.
6.1 The upright case: a grassland
In most ecosystems the pyramid of numbers is upright — wide at the bottom, narrow at the top — because many small producers support fewer, larger herbivores, which support fewer carnivores. A grassland example (illustrative numbers, per hectare at one census):
| Trophic level | Organisms | Individuals per hectare | Bar width |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | Producers (grass plants) | 1,000,000 | Widest |
| Level 2 | Primary consumers (grasshoppers) | 100,000 | |
| Level 3 | Secondary consumers (frogs) | 10,000 | |
| Level 4 | Tertiary consumers (snakes) | 1,000 | |
| Level 5 | Top carnivores (eagles) | 100 | Narrowest |
Each level holds one tenth of the individuals of the level below it in this teaching example — the same 10-to-1 pattern as the energy example, but here it is a count of individuals, not of energy. In a real grassland the ratios are not so neat, and body size matters: one grass plant is far smaller than one grasshopper, so a large number of small producers is needed to feed fewer, larger consumers.
6.2 The inverted case: one tree, thousands of insects
A pyramid of numbers can be inverted when one large producer supports many small consumers. The classic example is a single oak tree:
| Trophic level | Organisms | Individuals | Bar width |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | Producers (one oak tree) | 1 | Narrowest |
| Level 2 | Primary consumers (caterpillars, aphids, beetles) | 50,000 | Widest |
| Level 3 | Secondary consumers (insect-eating birds) | 50 | |
| Level 4 | Tertiary consumers (hawk) | 2 | Narrowest |
The base is a single individual — but that individual is enormous, lives for centuries, and produces a huge mass of leaves and acorns every year. Counting individuals hides that fact. The pyramid is inverted at the base, then narrows again above level 2, giving a spindle or diamond shape rather than a simple inverted triangle. A pyramid of numbers can therefore mislead when organisms at different levels differ greatly in size. That is why ecologists also measure biomass.
A common exam error is to say that an inverted pyramid of numbers is "wrong". It is not wrong — it is an accurate count. It simply shows that number of individuals is not the same as amount of living material or amount of energy.
7. Pyramid of biomass: weigh the living material
A pyramid of biomass shows the total dry mass of organisms at each trophic level — the standing crop — at one moment in a stated area. Dry mass is used, rather than fresh mass, because water content varies so much between organisms (a jellyfish is mostly water; a seed is mostly dry matter).
7.1 The upright case: a forest
In a forest, the standing crop is upright: the mass of trees is far greater than the mass of the animals that eat them (illustrative, dry mass per hectare at one census):
| Trophic level | Organisms | Dry biomass (kg ha⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | Producers (trees, shrubs, herbs) | 10,000 |
| Level 2 | Primary consumers (insects, deer, other herbivores) | 1,000 |
| Level 3 | Secondary consumers (insect-eating birds, small carnivores) | 100 |
| Level 4 | Tertiary consumers (owls, foxes) | 10 |
7.2 The inverted case: a pond
In a pond or lake, the pyramid of biomass is often inverted at the base — at any one moment, the mass of zooplankton can exceed the mass of the phytoplankton they eat:
| Trophic level | Organisms | Dry biomass (g m⁻²) at one census |
|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | Producers (phytoplankton) | 10 |
| Level 2 | Primary consumers (zooplankton) | 20 |
| Level 3 | Secondary consumers (small fish) | 12 |
| Level 4 | Tertiary consumers (large fish) | 2 |
How can consumers weigh more than their food? Because the numbers are a snapshot, not a total over time. Phytoplankton are tiny, short-lived and reproduce very fast — a population can double in a day. Zooplankton live for weeks and accumulate mass. At any instant there is little phytoplankton mass present, but over a whole year the phytoplankton produce far more mass than the zooplankton ever hold at one time. The pyramid of biomass confuses a snapshot (standing crop) with a flow (production). The pyramid of energy, in the next section, measures the flow — and that is why it never inverts.
Two terms to keep separate: standing crop is the biomass present at one moment; productivity is the rate at which new biomass is produced over time. An inverted biomass pyramid has a small standing crop of producers with a very high productivity. A forest has a huge standing crop of producers with a much lower productivity per unit of mass, because most of the tree's mass is wood that was built up over decades.
8. Pyramid of energy: the one that never turns upside down
A pyramid of energy shows the rate of energy flow through each trophic level — how much energy passes through the level per unit area per unit time, usually kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹. It is the most useful of the three pyramids, because it measures what actually sustains the level, not how many individuals happen to be present, nor how much they weigh at one instant.
It follows directly from the ten percent law in Post 1: on average, only about 10% of the energy at one level reaches the next, and the rest is lost as heat through respiration, or in egestion, excretion and uneaten material. So each level must be narrower than the one below it. An inverted energy pyramid would mean that a level contained more energy than the level that feeds it — which would require energy to be created, not merely transferred. That cannot happen.
8.1 Worked example: energy through four levels
The numbers below are an illustrative teaching example, not measurements from a real ecosystem. They use exactly 10% transfer at each step. Energy is in kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹.
| Trophic level | Organisms | Energy flow | Calculation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | Producers (grass) | 10,000 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹ | Starting point: net primary productivity |
| Level 2 | Primary consumers (grasshoppers) | 1,000 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹ | 10,000 × 0.10 = 1,000 |
| Level 3 | Secondary consumers (frogs) | 100 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹ | 1,000 × 0.10 = 100 |
| Level 4 | Tertiary consumers (snakes) | 10 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹ | 100 × 0.10 = 10 |
Check: each level holds one tenth of the level below it, and the top level holds 10 out of the original 10,000 units — 0.1% of the producers' energy. This is the same calculation as Post 1, now drawn as a pyramid. The shape is always upright, in every ecosystem, because the calculation is a flow, not a snapshot.
Try it yourself. Producers in an illustrative grassland fix 20,000 units of net energy. At 10% transfer, how much energy reaches trophic level 3? Level 2 receives 20,000 × 0.10 = 2,000 units. Level 3 receives 2,000 × 0.10 = 200 units.
Try it backwards. Trophic level 3 holds 40 units of energy and transfer efficiency is 10% at each step. How much energy did the producers hold? Working backwards: level 2 held 40 ÷ 0.10 = 400 units, and level 1 held 400 ÷ 0.10 = 4,000 units.
8.2 Why energy is the best pyramid for comparisons
- It cannot be inverted, so its shape always shows the same pattern: energy decreases up the chain.
- It measures a rate, not a snapshot, so it is not fooled by short-lived producers such as phytoplankton, or by one huge tree.
- It can compare ecosystems — a forest, a grassland and a pond can all be drawn in the same units (kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹) over the same year.
- It links directly to the ten percent law, so a student can calculate one level from another.
Its disadvantage is practical: measuring energy flow is hard work. It needs long-term measurements of photosynthesis, feeding, respiration and decomposition. Pyramids of numbers and biomass are easier to measure in the field, which is why they are still used — with their limitations stated.
9. Comparing the three pyramids — and choosing the right one
| Question | Pyramid of numbers | Pyramid of biomass | Pyramid of energy |
|---|---|---|---|
| What does it measure? | Individuals per area | Dry mass per area at one moment | Energy flow per area per time |
| Shape | Usually upright; inverted for a tree | Usually upright; inverted in a pond | Always upright |
| Main weakness | Misleading when body sizes differ greatly | A snapshot — confused by fast turnover | Hard and slow to measure |
| Best use | Quick census; showing the tree example | Comparing standing crops; forestry and fisheries | Comparing ecosystems; energy budgets; exam calculations |
Worked comparison — the same pond, three pyramids. A pond has, at one census, 10 g m⁻² of phytoplankton, 20 g m⁻² of zooplankton, 12 g m⁻² of small fish and 2 g m⁻² of large fish (Section 7.2). By number, the phytoplankton are countless, the zooplankton many, the fish few — an upright pyramid of numbers. By biomass, the pyramid is inverted at the base. By energy flow over a year, the pyramid is upright, because the phytoplankton produce far more energy over the year than the zooplankton consume at any moment. Three pyramids, one pond, three different shapes — and no contradiction, because they measure three different things. An exam answer that says "the pond pyramid is inverted" without saying which pyramid is incomplete.
A note on decomposers. Decomposers and detritivores are usually left out of ecological pyramids, or drawn to one side, because they feed on dead material from all levels. If they were placed on a single level, the pyramid would be misleading. The same caution applied in Post 1 to trophic levels: decomposers do not sit neatly on one level.
10. Active learning: interpret the evidence
Task 1. A food web diagram shows a fox with arrows arriving from rabbits, mice and frogs. A student says the fox is a primary consumer. Is that correct? No. The fox eats animals, so it is a secondary or higher consumer — a carnivore (and partly an omnivore if it also eats berries). It feeds at more than one trophic level, because rabbits and mice are primary consumers (level 2) while frogs are secondary consumers (level 3), so the fox is level 3 when it eats a rabbit and level 4 when it eats a frog.
Task 2. Sea otters are removed from a coast. Predict the next three changes, in order. Otter numbers fall → sea urchin numbers rise (fewer predators) → kelp is grazed down → fish and other kelp-dependent species decline. That is a top-down trophic cascade. A good answer also notes that the effect is disproportionate to the otters' small numbers — that is what makes the otter a keystone species.
Task 3. A pond's pyramid of biomass is inverted, but its pyramid of energy is upright. Explain how both can be true. The biomass pyramid is a snapshot of standing crop at one moment: phytoplankton are tiny and short-lived, so little mass is present at any instant, while zooplankton live longer and accumulate more mass. The energy pyramid measures the flow over a whole year: the phytoplankton produce far more energy over the year than the zooplankton hold at one moment, because they reproduce so fast. A snapshot can invert; a flow cannot.
Task 4. A student draws a pyramid of numbers for a grassland with 10 eagles at the base and 1,000,000 grass plants at the top. What is wrong? The pyramid is upside down. Producers always form the base of a pyramid of numbers (and of every ecological pyramid), and top predators form the narrow top. The bars should be widest at the bottom (producers) and narrowest at the top (eagles).
11. Misconceptions to correct
- "A food web is just a lot of food chains drawn together." A web is more than the sum of its chains: the cross-links give it alternative routes for energy, so it behaves differently from any single chain — it is usually more stable, and the loss of one species can spread in several directions.
- "The arrows in a food web point from the eater to the food." In the standard convention used here, arrows point from the food to the feeder — the direction energy flows. Always check the key on the diagram you are given, because some textbooks reverse the convention.
- "A keystone species is the most common species." The opposite: a keystone species has an effect far larger than its abundance suggests. The most abundant species is usually a producer, whose large effect is expected.
- "Removing a predator always harms the ecosystem." Removing a predator usually helps its prey in the short term — but in a web, the prey can then overgraze the producers and damage the whole community, as the urchin–kelp example shows.
- "An inverted pyramid is a mistake." Pyramids of number and biomass can be genuinely inverted, for the reasons in Sections 6 and 7. Only the energy pyramid can never be inverted.
- "Biomass and energy are the same thing." Biomass is a mass present at one moment (a stock); energy flow is a rate over time (a flow). A pond can have more zooplankton biomass than phytoplankton biomass at one moment, yet the phytoplankton still supply more energy over the year.
- "Top predators are the most numerous animals." Top predators are the least numerous, because only about 10% of the energy reaches each successive level. They need large territories and large prey populations beneath them.
- "The Yellowstone wolf story proves wolves alone restored the willows." Wolves contributed to a trophic cascade, but willow and aspen recovery also depended on climate, rainfall, beavers and elk numbers. In a web, several causes act at once.
12. Quick revision summary
A food chain is one path of energy flow; a food web is the network of all the feeding links in a community. In a web, most organisms have several food sources and several predators, many feed at more than one trophic level, and decomposers receive material from all levels.
A keystone species has an effect far larger than its abundance suggests, often by controlling a species that would otherwise dominate. Its removal (or return) causes a trophic cascade: sea otters → sea urchins → kelp, and wolves → elk → willows → beavers in Yellowstone. The Yellowstone case also shows that real cascades have several contributing causes, not one.
Food webs are usually more stable than single chains because predators can switch prey, prey have several predators, and most links are weak. Connectance measures how many of the possible feeding links actually exist, and it is usually low.
Ecological pyramids stack trophic levels as bars. The pyramid of numbers counts individuals and can be inverted (one oak → many insects). The pyramid of biomass weighs dry mass at one moment and can be inverted (a pond, where fast-reproducing phytoplankton support more zooplankton by mass). The pyramid of energy measures energy flow per area per time and can never be inverted, because only about 10% of the energy at one level reaches the next. Biomass is a snapshot; energy is a flow — and that distinction explains both inversions.
13. Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a food chain and a food web? A food chain is a single sequence (grass → grasshopper → frog → snake). A food web is the network formed by all the food chains in a community, with cross-links: each organism usually has several food sources and several predators.
Which way do the arrows point in a food web? In the convention used in this lesson, an arrow points from the organism being eaten to the organism eating it — the direction energy flows. Some textbooks use the opposite convention, so always check the key on the diagram.
Can a pyramid of energy ever be inverted? No. Each level receives only a fraction (on average about 10%) of the energy of the level below it, so each bar must be narrower than the one beneath it. An inverted energy pyramid would require energy to be created.
Why is the pyramid of biomass inverted in a pond? Because it is a snapshot. Phytoplankton reproduce very fast and are eaten quickly, so little phytoplankton mass is present at any one moment, while longer-lived zooplankton accumulate more mass. Over a whole year, the phytoplankton produce far more mass and energy than the zooplankton hold at one moment.
What is a keystone species, in one sentence? A species whose removal changes the community far more than its small abundance or biomass would suggest — for example, the sea otter, which protects kelp forests by eating sea urchins.
Why are there so few top predators? Because only about 10% of the energy at one trophic level reaches the next, so very little energy is left at the top. Top predators therefore have small populations and need large territories.
14. Twenty explained MCQs
Choose an answer before reading each explanation. Every question is drawn from the content of this post.
1. Which statement best describes a food web?
- A single sequence showing who eats whom
- A network of interconnected food chains in one community
- A diagram of the energy in one organism
- A list of all the producers in an ecosystem
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. A food web joins all the feeding links in a community into one network. Option A describes a food chain.
2. In the food web convention used in this lesson, an arrow from grass to a grasshopper means:
- The grasshopper is eaten by the grass
- Energy flows from the grass to the grasshopper — the grasshopper eats the grass
- The grasshopper produces the grass
- The grass and the grasshopper do not interact
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Arrows point in the direction energy flows, from food to feeder. Always check the key, because some textbooks reverse the convention.
3. A crow eats seeds and insects. What does this show about its trophic level?
- It is always a producer
- It feeds at more than one trophic level
- It is a decomposer
- It has no trophic level
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. The crow is a primary consumer (level 2) when it eats seeds and a secondary consumer (level 3) when it eats insects. Omnivores span levels.
4. Which of the following is a keystone species?
- The most abundant producer in a community
- A species whose effect on the community is far larger than its abundance suggests
- Any species at the top of a food chain
- The species with the largest biomass
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. A keystone species is defined by its disproportionate effect, not by abundance, biomass or position alone.
5. Sea otters are removed from a coast. What is the most likely sequence that follows?
- Sea urchins decrease, kelp increases
- Sea urchins increase, kelp decreases, kelp-dependent species decline
- Kelp increases and urchins increase together
- Nothing changes, because otters are rare
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Fewer otters → more urchins → kelp grazed down → loss of kelp-dependent species. This is a top-down trophic cascade.
6. In the Yellowstone wolf example, why should a student not say "wolves alone restored the willows"?
- Wolves do not eat elk
- Willow recovery also depended on climate, rainfall, beavers and elk numbers
- Wolves were never reintroduced to Yellowstone
- Willows do not grow in Yellowstone
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Wolves contributed to the cascade, but several causes acted at once. In a web, effects have more than one cause.
7. What is a trophic cascade?
- Water falling from one trophic level to the next
- A change at one trophic level that ripples through the levels above or below it
- The loss of energy as heat at each level
- A pyramid drawn with its base at the top
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. A cascade is a change that spreads through trophic levels — for example, fewer predators → more herbivores → fewer producers.
8. Why is a food web usually more stable than a single food chain?
- It has fewer species
- Predators can switch to alternative prey if one prey becomes scarce
- It has no top predators
- Energy is recycled in a web but not in a chain
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Alternative food sources (and alternative predators) give energy other routes when one link fails. Energy is not recycled in either case.
9. Connectance in a food web is:
- The number of species in the web
- The proportion of all possible feeding links that actually exist
- The total biomass of the web
- The length of the longest food chain
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Connectance = actual links ÷ possible links. Real webs usually have low connectance.
10. Who introduced the ecological pyramid, and in which year?
- Arthur Tansley, 1935
- Charles Elton, 1927
- Raymond Lindeman, 1942
- Eugene Odum, 1971
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Charles Elton introduced the ecological (Eltonian) pyramid in 1927. Tansley introduced "ecosystem" (1935) and Lindeman studied the ten percent law (1942).
11. A pyramid of numbers for a grassland is upright mainly because:
- Grass plants are larger than grasshoppers
- Many small producers support fewer, larger consumers at each higher level
- Energy pyramids are always inverted
- Decomposers are counted as producers
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Many producers are needed to feed fewer herbivores, which feed fewer carnivores. Grass plants are in fact smaller than grasshoppers, not larger.
12. The classic inverted pyramid of numbers is:
- A grassland with many grass plants and few eagles
- One oak tree supporting thousands of insects
- A pond with many phytoplankton and few fish
- A forest with many trees and few deer
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. One large oak supports many small insects, so the base bar (1 tree) is narrower than the bar above it (thousands of insects).
13. A pyramid of biomass measures:
- The number of individuals at each level
- The total dry mass of organisms at each level at one moment
- The rate of energy flow through each level
- The number of feeding links in a web
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Biomass is the standing crop — dry mass per area at one moment. Option C describes the pyramid of energy.
14. In a pond, the pyramid of biomass is often inverted at the base because:
- Phytoplankton produce no energy
- Phytoplankton are tiny, short-lived and reproduce fast, so little mass is present at any instant while zooplankton accumulate more
- Zooplankton photosynthesise
- Fish eat phytoplankton directly
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. The biomass pyramid is a snapshot. Over a whole year the phytoplankton produce far more mass than the zooplankton hold at one moment.
15. Which pyramid can never be inverted?
- Pyramid of numbers
- Pyramid of biomass
- Pyramid of energy
- All three can be inverted
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. The energy pyramid measures a flow, and each level receives only about 10% of the energy of the level below it, so it is always upright.
16. Using the worked example in this post, if producers hold 10,000 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹, how much energy reaches trophic level 4?
- 1,000 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹
- 100 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹
- 10 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹
- 1 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. Level 2 receives 10,000 × 0.10 = 1,000; level 3 receives 100; level 4 receives 10 kJ m⁻² yr⁻¹.
17. Producers fix 20,000 units of net energy. At 10% transfer, how much energy reaches trophic level 3?
- 2,000 units
- 200 units
- 20 units
- 20,000 units
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Level 2 receives 20,000 × 0.10 = 2,000 units, and level 3 receives 2,000 × 0.10 = 200 units.
18. Trophic level 3 holds 40 units of energy and transfer efficiency is 10% at each step. How much energy did the producers hold?
- 400 units
- 4,000 units
- 40,000 units
- 4 units
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Working backwards: level 2 held 40 ÷ 0.10 = 400 units, and level 1 held 400 ÷ 0.10 = 4,000 units.
19. A pond has 10 g m⁻² of phytoplankton and 20 g m⁻² of zooplankton at one census, but its energy pyramid is upright. The best explanation is:
- The biomass measurements must be wrong
- Biomass is a snapshot of standing crop, while energy is a flow over time — fast-reproducing phytoplankton produce far more energy over a year than their mass at one moment suggests
- Zooplankton are producers
- Energy pyramids are always inverted in ponds
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. The two pyramids measure different things: a snapshot (biomass) can invert, a flow (energy) cannot.
20. Decomposers are usually left out of ecological pyramids, or drawn to one side, because:
- They contain no energy
- They feed on dead material from all trophic levels, so they do not sit on a single level
- They are producers
- They are always the top predators
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Decomposers and detritivores receive material from every level, so placing them on one level would be misleading.
Sources and further study
The definitions, models and worked examples in this lesson follow standard university ecology texts. The teaching numbers are illustrative; the concepts and their history are as follows.
- Elton, C. (1927). Animal Ecology. Sidgwick & Jackson. Introduced the ecological pyramid.
- Paine, R. T. (1966). Food web complexity and species diversity. The American Naturalist, 100, 65–75. The starfish keystone experiment.
- Estes, J. A., & Palmisano, J. F. (1974). Sea otters: their role in structuring nearshore communities. Science, 185, 1058–1060. The otter–urchin–kelp cascade.
- Lindeman, R. L. (1942). The trophic-dynamic aspect of ecology. Ecology, 23, 399–417. The ten percent law, used in the energy pyramid worked example.
- Begon, M., Townsend, C. R., & Harper, J. L. (2006). Ecology: From Individuals to Ecosystems (4th ed.). Blackwell. Food webs, trophic cascades and pyramids.
- Ripple, W. J., & Beschta, R. L. (2012). Trophic cascades in Yellowstone: the first 15 years after wolf reintroduction. Biological Conservation, 145, 205–213 — and later work noting the roles of climate, beavers and elk numbers alongside wolves.
Continue your study: Plant Community Characteristics & Ecological Succession → Ecosystem Structure and Energy Flow (Post 1) → this food webs and pyramids lesson → next in this series: Biogeochemical Cycles. Return to Advanced Plant Ecology.
Reviewed for this draft on 18 November 2026. All photographs are real, openly licensed images with credits given under each figure. Teaching numbers and energy values are illustrative. Use your institution's current course outline to confirm assessment requirements.
0 Comments
Have a biology question or spotted an error?
Send feedback to PreachBio →